Job Board Highlights
New Conservation Documents

via ConserveOnline connecting conservation practitioners worldwide

Announcements

Looking for Contributors -Contact us, if you would like to profile new studies related to your area of interest.

Sign up for our newsletter - We profile the latest conservation studies from over 100 journals plus new funding opportunities... straight to your email.

Friday
Apr302010

Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective?

Colony of feral cats. The potential negative impact of feral cat populations on ecologically sensitive places has created perhaps the biggest bone of contention between the conservation movement and animal rights groups. 

This issue is particularly critical on islands where feral cats have been implicated in the extinction of a number of native species.

Some animal rights proponents have promoted "trap, neuter, and return" programs as a potential humane solution to the problem.

Under this approach, feral cats are trapped, sterilized, and then released back to local areas where volunteer "colony caretakers" provide periodic care.

One of the assumptions underlying the approach is that neutered cats will have smaller home ranges and will stick around the areas where they are being fed, which will keep them from preying on native wildlife in natural areas.

However, a new study from Santa Catalina Island of the coast of California challenges this assumption and raises questions about the effectiveness of using sterilization programs alone.

Efforts to control feral cats on Santa Catalina include trap, neuter and return (TNR) programs at the two villages at the ends of the island.

As part of their study published in the journal Mammalogy, researchers Darcee Guttilla and Paul Statt from California State University Fullerton conducted their own TNR experiment. They captured feral cats using traps, neutered half the sample, and released both sterilized and non-sterilized individuals outfitted with GPS collars.

They found little difference in the home-ranges between sterilized and non-sterilized cats. Neutered and non-neutered individuals traveled long distances between human populated areas and the interior of the island which is comprise primarily of wildlands.

They estimated the island-wide feral cat population at 600-750 individuals and found trapability to be very low.

The authors write, "The influx of subsidized cats to natural habitats, combined with their high vagility and low trappability, makes TNR an unlikely solution for controlling feral cats on a large, rugged island like Catalina and, more generally, in other locations where human populations abut ecologically sensitive areas."

This is bad news for native prey on the island including birds reptiles, and small mammals.

This is also problematic for the highly threatened Catalina Island fox, which has little immunity from diseases brought from the mainland and nearly went extinct after an outbreak of canine distemper virus.

Scientists worry that feral cats on the island - in addition to putting the fox at risk to disease - may also compete with the foxes for food and displace them from their habitat. Based on their findings, the authors write,

"Until resources are available to implement more proactive control measures in these areas, cats trapped in the island interior should be removed and delivered to a shelter; if they are deemed adoptable, cats should be sterilized and added to the adoption pool on the mainland. If they are not adoptable or if there are insufficient resources to support relocation, they should be euthanized."

--by Rob Goldstein

Guttilla, D., & Stapp, P. (2010). Effects of sterilization on movements of feral cats at a wildland–urban interface Journal of Mammalogy, 91 (2), 482-489 DOI: 10.1644/09-MAMM-A-111.1

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (48)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: Play roulette
    There is noticeably a bunch to realize about this. I believe you made certain nice points in features also.
  • Response
    Response: www.uglycars.co.uk
    Thanks for blogging and i enjoy the blog posting so no public comments.,,,,,,,,,,,
  • Response
    TYVM, nice job! This was the information I needed to get.
  • Response
    Response: maniva.it
    This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! Keep up the good work.
  • Response
    Response: www.hodges.co.za
    Amazing points=) I am going to take a bit of time to toy with the post.
  • Response
    Response: www.gmc-om.com
    Then again, the opposite could be true. Modern dancing is old fashioned. Samuel Goldwyn 1882 1974
  • Response
    Response: www.marcethier.com
    Hey, maybe this is a bit offf topic but in any case, I have been surfing about your blog and it looks really neat. impassioned about your writing. I am creating a new blog and hard-pressed to make it appear great, and supply excellent articles. I have discovered a lot on ...
  • Response
    レイバン黄色飛行士
  • Response
    find BuildABear Workshop deals, BuildABear Workshop reviews at http://www.dealsextra.com.au/business/Build_2AA_2ABear-Workshop.php
  • Response
    Response: activewomen
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Affiloblueprint
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: see more
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: zombie dai chien
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: dieta Dos pontos
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: web designers
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: best hosting vps
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Spire Ecig
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Vps coupon
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: universal tv stand
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: audit seo
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: www.Gotvwins.com
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Nuvoderm
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: harvest url
    Controlling feral cats in ecologically sensitive areas: Is "trap, neuter, return" effective? - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
  • Response

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.