Job Board Highlights
New Conservation Documents

via ConserveOnline connecting conservation practitioners worldwide

Announcements

Looking for Contributors -Contact us, if you would like to profile new studies related to your area of interest.

Sign up for our newsletter - We profile the latest conservation studies from over 100 journals plus new funding opportunities... straight to your email.

Tuesday
Oct042011

Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue 

A newly released and collared wolf in Yellowstone National Park. Credit, Barry O'Neill.When a species recovers enough to be removed from the federal endangered species list, the public trust doctrine – the principle that government must conserve natural resources for the public good – should guide state management of wildlife, scientists say.

In the Sept. 30 issue of the journal Science, the researchers note that the public trust doctrine holds that certain natural resources, including wildlife, have no owners and therefore belong to all citizens. So, they add, when federal statutory law no longer offers protection to a species, the public trust doctrine imposes upon states an obligation to conserve the species for their citizens.

The researchers cite the case of the gray wolf, which lost federal protection in the northern Rocky Mountains last spring under a rare Congressional legislative rider. This rider was passed after courts had reversed three previous U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service attempts to delist the wolf in the region, which includes Idaho, Montana and parts of Oregon, Washington and Utah.

The merits of protecting gray wolves have been hotly debated for years in the northern Rocky Mountains, where public opinion varies considerably among livestock owners, hunters and wildlife advocates. Idaho and Montana have launched public hunts aimed at reducing wolf populations since federal protections were lifted. Wolf advocates fear that heavy-handed “lethal management” of wolves could deplete the population so rapidly that the species will require federal protections again. Under the Endangered Species Act, the federal government monitors a species for at least five years after it is delisted, but state wildlife agencies take over management.

Lost in these bitter arguments is any attempt to clarify state agencies’ obligation to their citizens, said Jeremy Bruskotter, assistant professor in Ohio State University’s School of Environment and Natural Resources and lead author of the Science paper.

The wildlife trust doctrine, a branch of the public trust doctrine, defines that obligation, the paper’s authors argue. The public trust doctrine has roots in ancient Roman and English common law, but its application to wildlife in the United States dates to the late 19th century. In an 1896 case, Geer vs. Connecticut, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the wildlife trust doctrine imposed on states a duty “to enact such laws as will best preserve the subject of the trust and secure its beneficial use in the future to the people of the state.”

“If you recognize a wildlife trust doctrine, and that the state has the obligation to maintain these populations in perpetuity not just for current residents but for future residents, then there is a degree of protection for species in the absence of the statutory protection,” Bruskotter said.

The researchers note that natural resource agency professionals are likely to be aware that all wildlife are communally owned by each state, but western politicians’ open hostility toward this formerly protected species raises the question: What are states actually going to do?

“Some of the rhetoric about the killing of wolves might be political showmanship. But when they make exaggerated claims – for example, comparing wolf restoration to the resurrection of the T. rex, which was done in Utah – that adds layers of ambiguity and fear. Conservationists wonder if they will try to eliminate wolves and wonder if they can do it,” Bruskotter said. “But the public trust doctrine holds that if state politicians were to intervene to try to prevent the maintenance of a viable wolf population, they could be taken to court. There is a legal mechanism to prevent that type of action.”

Traditionally, the conservation and management of wildlife resources in the United States has been driven by state governments, which established agencies to monitor wildlife populations and regulate activities like hunting and trapping. However, the federal government began to take an interest in imperiled species in the 1960s, culminating with the passage of the Endangered Species Act in 1973.

“This is where the conflict turns. Until then, the impetus for wildlife management had come primarily from the states. Then the feds came in and said, ‘We’re taking over the protection and, hopefully, the recovery,’” Bruskotter said.

The federally led reintroduction of gray wolves to western states didn’t sit well with many of those states’ officials, who characterized the action as an unwanted federal intervention. When the wolf population was deemed to have met federal recovery goals in the region in 2002, state politicians began “clamoring for management authority,” Bruskotter said.

To date, wildlife advocates haven’t had to rely on the wildlife trust doctrine to guide their management because states generally show a strong desire to conserve species. The case of gray wolves in the northern Rockies has been unusual, with western legislatures continually expressing the desire to minimize or even remove wolf populations altogether.

While case law exists to define the reach of the public trust doctrine, additional case law would be beneficial to firmly establish states’ obligations in the management of species no longer covered by federal protection, the authors contend.

“If this obligation is going to be more than just understood, there will need to be case law established, which is going to require somebody to take things to court to see what those obligations are,” said Sherry Enzler, a co-author of the paper and a public trust scholar at the University of Minnesota.

The authors note that this argument for the application of the wildlife trust doctrine should not be construed as an appeal on behalf of the gray wolf.

“It’s not about protecting any particular species. It’s about how we ensure we have adequate protection for all imperiled species under state-led management. Not all species are a perfect fit for federal protection, so this is a better long-term solution,” Bruskotter said.

“There is a middle ground here, and there is a legal process for defining this middle ground. States have an obligation to maintain, at minimum, a viable population of a species that has been removed from the endangered species list.”

Better clarity about state management could also apply to the case of the grizzly bear, which the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service stands ready to delist in the greater Yellowstone region. As part of a recent plan to remove protection, federal officials asked states to agree to certain management practices under a series of memoranda of understanding. A federal court rejected the plan because the memoranda were not legally binding – states could not be compelled to conserve.

“This court-made law could be that regulatory mechanism,” Bruskotter said, noting that this represents how the wildlife trust doctrine’s application could support delisting a previously threatened species. “This common law could have been used to help remove grizzly bears from protection because it could have provided the regulatory mechanism the court sought in that case.”

--Reprinted from Ohio State University

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (100)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: Online roulette
    Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn anything like this before. So good to seek out any individual with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thanks for beginning this up. this web site is something that's needed on the internet, someone with a bit of originality. useful job for ...
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue  - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    NFL is truly a single of the largest sports in America. It has a big following.
  • Response
    Response: sac lancelle
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue  - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: lancel collection
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue  - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: sac lancel flirt
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue  - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: ugg noir
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue  - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: index service
    Excellent Site, Continue the fantastic work. Regards!
  • Response
    It means i create a database using mysql and create a website using joomla so when i click a link from the web i can directly retrieve the data from mysql server.
  • Response
    Response: company rescue
    Hi all - I have a straight-up HTML website that I'd like to transition to Joomla. If possible, I'd like to install Joomla into a subfolder and create and test the site there, while keeping the existing site functioning until I'm ready to move it over. Is this possible?. . Thanks!. ...
  • Response
    How can I install WordPress without losing all the indexed html pages?
  • Response
    I always hear that Fire fox is better than Internet Explorer and its faster safer ect....But what are the bad things about firefox?.
  • Response
    I have seen a lot of blogs in blogspot. What purpose do they serve? Is it possible to make money through blogs. If yes how?.
  • Response
    They are noteworthy for the possibly of the making of a book..
  • Response
    Response: college ira
    How do you protect articles put on a website against copyright infringement?
  • Response
    Response: silver coins
    There are a lot of blogging sites dedicated to celebrities (ex. Perez Hilton), love, fashion, travel, and food. But, how do I start one of my own specialty?.
  • Response
    I'm interested in fashion and I want to start a blog but I have no idea where to start or how to get people interested in my blog. Any ideas welcome..
  • Response
    I'm in high school and starting next year I will have to start looking at colleges. I know I want to find a college just for creative writing. I love writing stories of all sorts, and I know of a couple colleges that specialize in creative writing. But where would you ...
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: light bulbs
    How to make a select category on wordpress use a different domain?
  • Response
    Response: financial advisor
    What are the most effective Wordpress plugins to attract the most relevant traffic and maximize website sales?
  • Response
    I need to earn a little extra money and I am a very opinionated person so I feel like writing blogs would be a good start to making some extra cash. I am a full time college student and I also have a $20 hour a week job but I am ...
  • Response
    Response: roofing supplies
    I started creating templates, but I don't know how to make demos in my Joomla website, for my visitors to test them..
  • Response
    I always used to think that, while, the first word meant a person who blogs, the second word stood for a blog hosting site! Now, I am utterly confused because my uncle tells me, that both of them are the same hosting site for those who blog with Google using blogger/blogspot! ...
  • Response
    Response: my company
    I always used to think that, while, the first word meant a person who blogs, the second word stood for a blog hosting site! Now, I am utterly confused because my uncle tells me, that both of them are the same hosting site for those who blog with Google using blogger/blogspot! ...
  • Response
    On my friend's blogs they have added me on their blog rolls, but mine always sits at the bottom of the list and does not list when I post like it does for others. Is this a setting that I need to change or is this a choice that they have ...
  • Response
    what is the procedure to copyright a blog content (text and images)?
  • Response
    Where or what would I have to do? And what's the cost?.
  • Response
    Response: Emergency Plumbers
    I'm currently using a classic blogger template and I would like to know how you put an rss feed on it. Normally, blogger has an rss feed avaliable on the newer templates but my blog doesn't have one. Also, is there some sort of widget I could also install for followers?. ...
  • Response
    Response: sr22 filing
    How to start a blog. Kindly suggest books on the subject?
  • Response
    Response: insurance claims
    How can I keep up with posts made on the Blogspot websites?
  • Response
    Response: learn here
    How do I export my Blogspot blogs to my Weebly blog?
  • Response
    Response: house
    I'm new to blogging and I am using Tumblr. I want to make sure no one obtains my content or background images and pictures. If anyone has any suggestions I would really appreciate it. Thanks!.
  • Response
    Response: helpful hints
    I have a Joomla website and already set up a Google Analytics account, now how do I add the code to my website so that it will keep track of visitors etc to every page? Thanks!.
  • Response
    Response: create backlinks
    I want to start a blog that deals with moral issues. I want people to be able to see it, and also be easy to use and post..
  • Response
    Response: use this link
    I use firefox and some nights at 12:00 exactly or 12:30 exactly, firefox stops working and does not load a page. The internet connection is perfectly fine though because it says excellent. I am connected to a home router and the signal strength is always excellent. I do not know why ...
  • Response
    Response: freight + volume
    How can I get a blogger to remove a defammatory post on a blog?
  • Response
    Response: демиарт
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: agree with
    What is the best blogging platform for a podcast or a video blog?
  • Response
    How do I get "undefined" on my blog posts? There are 3 undefined words right below the title of my blog post. How do I get rid of it?.
  • Response
    Response: get the facts
    What are the most popular blog sites in the Philippines where I can submit my blogs for others to read?
  • Response
    Response: official website
    could someone explain to me exactly how I would make money blogging?
  • Response
    Response: insurance coverage
    What Firefox Extension can I get to download streaming videos from sites?
  • Response
    How do you start a blog? How do you get your own blog site or page?
  • Response
    Response: official source
    Computer question (How long does an average person keep a computer for?
  • Response
    Response: read here
    Is there a way to report a website for violating copyright of articles and images?
  • Response
    Response: discover this
    How can I automatically publish my blog posts to Facebook?
  • Response
    Response: clicking here
    I have a business blog through which I offer certain goods and services. It is also a general-information blog, however. I am seeking to move it to another blog host. I know that blogspot offers user-sponsored advertising, but are there any other free blogs that allow something like blogspot's adsense and/or ...
  • Response
    Response: their explanation
    I'm looking to spike my journalistic career and thought that a blog might be a good idea. But I also know that there are ways to set up a paypal account attached to the blog for payment to read it or donate. I guess I was inspired by the movie Julia ...
  • Response
    Response: try what he says
    Where can i get hindu religious Joomla templates for hindu temples ?
  • Response
    Response: servicios seo
    get top quality posicionamiento web en google available
  • Response
    Response: at yahoo
    I am developing a joomla website for a boat club and would like members to be able to upload photos of fish they caught. Additional info: I am basing the structure on the K2 component..
  • Response
    get the best car insurance company anywhere
  • Response
    What is the best way to search for blogs you are interested in?
  • Response
    Response: paid search ma
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: gold ira rollover
    So I created a secondary blog off my first one, but I now want my secondary blog to be my personal or my main blog. So that as soon and I sign on the newer blog I made would be my default blog. If that makes any sense... Is there a ...
  • Response
    How can I search blog posts from during the olympics?
  • Response
    I'm trying to use software to erase the information on my old computer before donating it. The mouse is not working on the computer. I've tried another mouse on the computer and it still will not work. I need to reboot my computer in order to start the disc wiper. Is ...
  • Response
    Response: experto seo
    go here for best que significa seo around
  • Response
    get best dog arthritis medication anywhere
  • Response
    Response: hgh reviews
    Just started my own blog on Blogspot need help with header?
  • Response
    go here for best wordpress work around
  • Response
    Response: croatia property
    I have the game and when I tried it on my computer, it was all broken up and crappy. I'm thinking of buying a new computer anyway. Does anyone know of a computer where the game works well?.
  • Response
    get greatest arthritis dog treatment available
  • Response
    How do I become a blogger in the food and drink category?
  • Response
    Response: File your review
    I need to find blogging websites that deal with legal issues such as contracts, wrongful death claims, fraud, etc. I don't even know where to start looking. Any advice would be appreciated.. . Thanks..
  • Response
    What are some great ideas on teaching creative writing to kids?
  • Response
    What is the best way to search for blogs you are interested in?
  • Response
    Response: wood stove liner
    How do I copy my Wordpress blog onto my computer so I can locally edit and try out plugins before publishing?
  • Response
    Does Joomla have a Component that help to create a forum like Yahoo Answers?
  • Response
    I have a Blogspot blog, and I want that any time I publish a new post on my blog, a link to the new post will automatically be added to my Facebook news feed. Is there anyway to do this?.
  • Response
    Response: health insurance
    I want to switch to a clean new WordPress theme for a site, but Google has indexed 2500 pages from the old site (mainly due to a calendar module creating a new page for each day). How do I ensure all those pages remain accessible for Google, without throwing up a ...
  • Response
    see here for best canine arthritis anywhere
  • Response
    Response: homeowners
    I just figured out that my computer has this kind of trojan. I was running pretty much all of the Anti-virus things my computer has. The main one says there is nothing there and my Windows defender says I have two trojans so I'm not sure what to do. I'm thinking ...
  • Response
    see here for greatest arthritic dogs around
  • Response
    I was thinking of starting a blog so I did some research into it on the internet and came across a lot of stuff that talks about legal issues and blogging. I'm not planning on blogging about controversial issues, (my blog would focus on posts about books, movies, culture, theater, music ...
  • Response
    How do you keep blogger from counting your page views on your blog?
  • Response
    Response: unlock iphone 5s
    How to add article to Joomla using a blackberry or other mobile device?
  • Response
    How to get your customized blogspot to appear on google search?
  • Response
    Is it possible to copy and paste news articles for my blog or is that copyright infringement?
  • Response
    I want to start website very soon but I need to know certain costs. What factors did you have to pay for when you started up our website?. . How much was a website designer?. How much was your domain name?. What is your monthly rent for the domain name?. How ...
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: diet plans
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: milf dating
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Samsung galaxy
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: shop fitting
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: namecheap domain
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: namecheap domain
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Digitalocean vps
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: goloveparametry.cz
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven
  • Response
    Response: Orlando AC Repair
    Public trust doctrine can rescue wildlife from politics, scientists argue - Conservation News - Conservation Maven

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.